THE |
|
a cache of usenet and other text files pertaining
to occult, mystical, and spiritual subjects. |
To: alt.tarot,alt.magick,alt.magick.tyagi From: tarotica@jktarot.com (jk) Subject: Re: Tarot Card Games and Crypto Jews (3) Date: 15 May 2003 13:47:17 -0700 Catherine Yronwodewrote in message news:<3EC1754B.E13160E5@luckymojo.com>... > jk wrote: >>> but the tradition of linking Tarot to Kabbalah began with the >>> Egyptomaniacal theories of French Freemasons: > I used to believe as you do about this, Jess: I took a rationalist > viewpoint--- As opposed to what, an irrationalist viewpoint? Being irrational is certainly a Tarot tradition, but it isn't useful in determining the facts of history, including the history of Tarot. > , that i since i could see no logical reason why the Kabbalah > was linked to playing cards (tarocchi or tarock decks)--- There is a logical reason why the Kabbalah was linked to Tarot (which is a peculiar kind of playing cards), and that reason is evident to people who know something about Tarot and Kabbalah---they share a numerical motif of twenty-two symbols. That alone is sufficient to explain why people, already given to making metaphysical speculations about the meanings of Tarot's "mysterious" trumps, would make the Kabbalistic connection. This tendency is strengthened when you consider who made the connection---i.e., people already invested in Egyptian (or Egyptomaniacal) and Apocalyptic dogmas, the very Freemasons who invented occult Tarot. That is not a conjecture. That is a fact. > , it was logical to assume that any such claimed the linkage > was a fantasy on the part of Hermetic Egyptomaniacs. It's only logical to conclude that IF you've got evidence to support that conclusion. That same rule governs your conjecturing. And you have not met even the least rigorous standard for supplying convincing evidence for your claim. You have instead invented a story to fit the absence of any supporting facts for your conjecture. > The article cited at the beginning of this discussion--- ---also offers conjectures, not fact-based arguments. That some people have some stories about some behaviors, or even if they presently exhibit those behaviors, is simply insufficient evidence to support the claims you're making about what those stories or behaviors indicate. You are acting like the occultists who invented the Egyptian Tarot mythology. They also weren't good historians. > The mention of this linkage arose OUTSIDE the realm of Tarot > scholarship -- And as you yourself admit---IT DOESN'T MENTION TAROT. You need first to address that glaring shortcoming of your conjectures. The answer, or dodge, you've manufactured, is again insufficient. > and in the much more staid and less-fantasy-prone realm > of Crypto Jewish scholarship. How much Crypto-Jewish scholarship have you actually read? Perhaps the lack of mention of the use by Crypto-Jews of Tarot cards is the result of this avoidance of fantasy in that field of study. You might try emulating that cautious approach. > The mention of this linkage did not arise with reference to tarot > cards per se -- but tarocchi / trionfi / tarock games were and are in > the region where Jews were forced to convert or become Crypto Jews. Once again, Tarot wasn't produced in Spain until lately, and that's because there is no tradition of Tarot game play in Spain. They have plenty of other card games, using the distinctive Spanish cards (which look different from Italian and French cards), but Tarot never caught on in Spain until it was adopted, as it was in the UK and the United States, as a fortune-telling deck. So, what you would have us believe is that--- 1. Jews wished to mask their true beliefs by hiding a Jewish practice under the guise of playing cards. 2. The deck of cards (Tarot) they chose for this purpose was rare in Spain, and so likely to draw attention to its users for that reason alone. 3. If only or mainly Jews or Crypto Jews used Tarot, again a rare deck of cards in Spain, for this purpose, eventually that fact would have been discerned by the Inquisition (which is after all our source for much of the information concerning the practices of Crypto Jews). In other words, if Crypto Jews used Tarots it might have marked them as Crypto Jews in a way that using regular Spanish card decks would not have done. You have offered NO evidence to support the idea that the cards these Jews were supposedly using were Tarot cards. No evidence is an insufficient amount. > Further, i believe that the linkage between these card decks and the > teaching of the Torah as revealed in the study of Crypto Jewish > history--- First off, what is revealed in the "study" is merely a claim about this, nothing documented, and it is claimed to be a family custom, not a regional one. So we don't have any indication this practice (of teaching Torah with playing cards) was widespread, nor even that it was actually something inherited as a tradition from centuries earlier. > makes sense of the seemingly senseless connection between the > cards and Kabbalah--- Again, the connection between Tarot and Kabbalah is not senseless. It is simply not accurate with respect to the historical basis claimed for it by occultists. In fact, the reason the connection was made was that it was so obvious, so attractive to make it. It didn't require much pondering, or even irrational guesswork, to SEE it. But it did require more skepticism to confirm it than occultists were usually prepared to use. > One of the most convincing points in this argument to me is that the > origin of the linkage between playing cards and Crypto Jewish > religious practices is both dated and located appropriately -- namely, > to 1492, the year of the Spanish expulsion of the Jews from all > regions they controlled, including Sicily in Italy. But you're talking here about people who were Crypto Jews, so people who presumably wouldn't have been expelled because they were pretending NOT to be Jews. > I say that this is "appropriate" in date and location because > the date falls well after the invention of tarocchi as a game > and Sicily is well within the expected spread of tarocchi card > decks throughout Italy, including those Italian regions controlled > by Spain at the time and thus under the Spanish edict of > Jewish expulsion. So what exactly is it you're trying to say happened? Be very specific. > Side note -- Sea-faring Jewish merchants regularly travelled the > Mediterranean--- But that doesn't mean any of them were engaged in transporting Tarot decks to Spanish Crypto Jews, especially for the purposes you wish to claim. Again, you offer NO evidence, merely baseless conjecture. > The fact that the custom of using playing cards as religious tools > persists among Crypto Jews to this day -- It has not been demonstrated that this is a widespread or persistent practice among Crypto Jews, or any Jews. > 500 years after its origin--- That also has not been demonstrated. You are inventing fiction, not offering historical speculation. Again, no facts, the amount you're supplying here, is insufficient. > -- indicates that it was a widely-based practice--- If your fiction were true in all particulars it might indicate this, yes, but your fiction is only that, a baseless conjecture. >> Catherine indicated in her posting that the information at the >> link she provided "may shed light on the commonly held >> Hermetic belief that tarot or tarocchi game cards contain >> hidden symbolism relating to the Jewish Kabbalah." > Yes, and i will now go a step farther, Jess. Why? You have offered absolutely no evidence to build any additional steps to your initial baseless conjecture. > Based on this new information (new to me -- and apparently new to the > world of tarot research, since i have not encountered it anywhere > except in scholarship about Crypto Jews)--- "this new information" is your invention, not anything supported by the article whose link you provided. > i am now radically reversing my stand on the origins of what > i considered to be a "myth" on the part of Hermetic authors. Other than the confessional content, which perhaps has relevance on some "support" group somewhere, the value of this reversal is not evident with respect to enlightening anyone concerning Tarot history. > In short, i now think that the Hermetics--- Which "Hermetics"? Be specific. > In short, i now believe that the association of > tarocchi cards with Jewish mysticism predated the rise of the > occult-Egyptomania craze--- Catherine, you don't even understand the meaning of the terms you're attempting to employ, nor their historical relevance. You're talking ignorantly about things which only interest you to the extent you're being given a public correction here. That correction will not cease merely because your exploitation of your own ignorance expands in scope from the merely questionable to the ludicrous. > I now believe--- What you believe is really not that interesting or pertinent to the issues you pretend to address. What you can document, what you can support with facts and educated analyses, MIGHT be welcome, but that's not what you're offering. > The fact that a specific and unique Ladino word for playing cards - > "barajas" -- exists in New Mexico among Crypto Jews, when the rest of > the Spanish-speaking world calls these objects "cartas"--- The "rest of the Spanish-speaking world" is quite large and varied and uses forms of baraj- to indicate several card-playing ideas, including decks and shuffling. I've not checked the etymology but I doubt it's Hebrew in origin. > This leaves only one link incomplete -- Yes, and using your approach you should be able to also demonstrate the existence of Bigfoot-prints on the ocean floor in the middle of the Bermuda Triangle. No doubt some Atlantean connection can be made to this amazing (but also baseless) claim. > the jump from the known teaching of Torah and/or the > observance of Jewish prayer via playing cards to the > not-yet-proven teaching of Jewish mystical Kabbalah via > playing cards. No "jump" of this sort is required if you have not supported your claims, and you haven't. > However, given the early date of 1492 for the start of > the custom of using tarocchi to teach Torah, i think that the link to > Kabbalah can be safely assumed--- For nitwits, perhaps. Not for people seriously interested in Tarot history. For the latter, "safety" is not merely a matter of feeling good about one's latest imitation of Mary K. Greer---or Eric von Daniken. > Finally, we have the question of the "Egyptian" connection to tarot. > Why Egypt? http://jktarot.com/egyptomania.html > I suggest that if you wish to look into this further, from a > researcher's point of view rather than a dogmatist's--- But you ARE a dogmatist, and certainly not evidently any kind of reliable researcher. The question of "why Egypt?" has been convincingly answered already, without need of any Crypto Jewish inspirations. [long irrelevant bit snipped] Catherine, let me make you a suggestion. By all means send your ideas, with an appropriate summary of where you'd like to take them, off to a publisher. And you'd better do it quickly before someone steals your "research". I have no doubt your book about the Crypto-Jewish origins of occult Tarot would be unduly popular. I also have no doubt that jktarot.com will welcome the opportunity to review it in torturously painstaking detail. (jk) ************************************ Read jk's Tarot FAQ: http://jktarot.com/faq.html Tarot News: http://www.jktarot.com/news.html ************************************
The Arcane Archive is copyright by the authors cited.
Send comments to the Arcane Archivist: tyaginator@arcane-archive.org. |
Did you like what you read here? Find it useful?
Then please click on the Paypal Secure Server logo and make a small donation to the site maintainer for the creation and upkeep of this site. |
The ARCANE ARCHIVE is a large domain,
organized into a number of sub-directories, each dealing with a different branch of religion, mysticism, occultism, or esoteric knowledge. Here are the major ARCANE ARCHIVE directories you can visit: |
|
interdisciplinary:
geometry, natural proportion, ratio, archaeoastronomy
mysticism: enlightenment, self-realization, trance, meditation, consciousness occultism: divination, hermeticism, amulets, sigils, magick, witchcraft, spells religion: buddhism, christianity, hinduism, islam, judaism, taoism, wicca, voodoo societies and fraternal orders: freemasonry, golden dawn, rosicrucians, etc. |
SEARCH THE ARCANE ARCHIVE
There are thousands of web pages at the ARCANE ARCHIVE. You can use ATOMZ.COM
to search for a single word (like witchcraft, hoodoo, pagan, or magic) or an
exact phrase (like Kwan Yin, golden ratio, or book of shadows):
OTHER ESOTERIC AND OCCULT SITES OF INTEREST
Southern
Spirits: 19th and 20th century accounts of hoodoo,
including slave narratives & interviews
|